







Free written scope consultation - allowances, timeline, and change-order rules on paper before a single trade is scheduled
Styles & brands we work with
- Kitchen remodeling
- Bathroom remodeling
- Home additions & ADU
- Roofing
- Windows & doors
- Driveway & pavers
- Fence
See the difference
Before
After
Before
After
Before
AfterTub vs Walk-In Shower in El Monte, CA: Which One Belongs in Your Bathroom?
Keep the tub unless your bathroom isn’t the only one on the property. For most El Monte homes with a single full bath, tearing out the only tub to gain shower space is a resale gamble that rarely pays off in this price band. If you’re adding a rear ADU or converting the garage to a unit with its own full bath, the math flips and a walk-in shower in the main house becomes the smarter move. Call (888) 271-7872 and we’ll price both configurations side by side before you commit to anything.

Why this question comes up so often in El Monte
Walk down almost any block of the postwar single-story homes that fill this city and you’ll see the pattern: a garage quietly turning into living space, a rear unit going up behind the main house, a second family moving in. Most of that housing stock went up between the 1940s and 1960s, with one full bathroom serving three bedrooms. When those homeowners start planning a remodel, the first real decision isn’t tile or vanity. It’s whether the tub stays.
The honest answer depends less on how you bathe and more on what the property needs to be worth. In El Monte, where multi-generational households are the norm and ADU conversions are everywhere, a second wet space protects value far better than a soaking tub ever will. That’s the calculation we walk through with every homeowner before demo starts.
What resale actually looks like for a 3/1 or 3/2 in this market
Buyers in this price band expect at least one tub somewhere on the property. It’s not nostalgia. It’s the family with a toddler, the adult child moving back in with aging parents, the renter who wants to soak after a shift. When you strip the only tub out of a three-bedroom house to gain a few inches of shower, appraisers and buyers notice, and the comps down the street won’t do you any favors.
So the rule we give homeowners is simple: count your tubs before you remove one. If that walk-in shower leaves the property with zero tubs, you’re trading daily comfort for a resale hit you probably won’t recover in this market.

How an ADU changes the whole equation
Here’s where El Monte differs from most of the San Gabriel Valley. Because so many homes add a rear unit or convert the detached garage, the property often ends up with two full baths even though it started with one. Once the ADU carries its own tub-and-shower combo, the main house is free to convert its tub alcove into a walk-in shower without touching the property’s resale math at all.
The catch is sequencing. Pull the main-house tub before the ADU permits clear plan check, and you’ve removed your only tub with nothing to replace it. On the infill lots typical here, tight setbacks and the city’s plan-check scrutiny on second units can stretch a timeline. We plan the wet spaces together so the main bath doesn’t go tub-less in the gap.
What a 40-square-foot bathroom really gains
Most El Monte hall baths land around 40 square feet. Convert the standard 60-inch tub alcove to a walk-in shower with a bench and a recessed niche and you net roughly 6 to 8 more usable square inches of floor. That’s not a lot of square footage. What you gain is the daily experience: no stepping over a 15-inch tub wall, no tripping hazard on a wet curb, room to actually move your elbows.
For older homeowners and anyone aging in place, that difference matters more than any spec sheet. A low-threshold shower with proper blocking behind the tile and a grab bar planned in from the start beats a tub you can’t safely get out of. We build the framing for that support whether or not the bar goes in day one.
Cost comparison before you commit
Upfront pricing is the only way this decision gets made with clear eyes. Here’s how the two configurations pencil out in El Monte, and these are the numbers we hold to:
| Project | Typical El Monte range |
|---|---|
| Tub-to-shower conversion | $3,500-$10,000 |
| Walk-in shower installation | $4,500-$12,000 |
| Shower replacement | $3,000-$8,500 |
| Full bathroom remodel | $9,000-$28,000 |
| Small bathroom remodel | $5,000-$12,000 |
Keep the tub as-is and refresh around it? Smaller number. Convert to a shower? The tub-to-shower line applies, and it climbs toward the walk-in figure once you add a bench, niche, and new valve. The pricing above holds unless the demo opens a wall and finds what we regularly run into in these homes: tile set over crumbling greenboard, a leaking valve, or galvanized supply lines that have to go. We quote both paths before anyone signs, so a surprise behind the tile doesn’t become a surprise on the invoice.
Water use under SGVMWD tiered rates
It’s dry here. Hot San Gabriel Valley summers and periodic Santa Ana winds mean water is a real budget line, and the tiered rates homeowners pay climb fast once you’re past the baseline. A 10-minute shower at 2.0 gallons per minute uses about 20 gallons. A tub fill averages 36 to 50. Over a year, that gap shows up on the bill, and if you’re weighing a low-flow walk-in shower against a tub you seldom use, the water math favors the shower in a drought market.
That’s a genuine argument for the shower when the property has another tub to fall back on. When it doesn’t, the resale consideration outweighs the water savings.
Three local scenarios and what we recommend
- Three-bedroom, one-bath, no second unit planned. Keep the tub. Refresh the surround and the vanity, and put your money into waterproofing, not demolition. Removing the only tub here works against your comps.
- Garage converting to an ADU with its own full bath. Convert the main-house tub to a walk-in shower once the ADU permits are through plan check. The second unit absorbs the tub requirement and the main bath gets the daily-use upgrade.
- Two-bath house, primary bath has a tub nobody uses. Convert the primary to a walk-in shower and keep the hall bath’s tub for resale. That’s the cleanest version of this decision and the one we recommend most often.
Materials matter here more than most people expect. We work with brands like Kohler for fixtures and Cambria or Silestone for vanity tops, so the choices are quality, not just what’s in stock. Browse our home page to see the full range of what we install, and our Bathroom Remodeling team handles the tub-to-shower work end to end. If you’re ready to plan it out, start with Bathroom Remodeling in El Monte.
Every project comes with our 730-Day Done Right Promise. If something isn’t done right, we make it right. Calls are answered by a live person around the clock, and our background-checked, uniformed technicians show up ready to work. We also offer 0% financing for 18 months and $1,000 off projects over $10,000, which takes some of the sting out of the bigger remodel numbers.
FAQs
Keeping the tub is cheaper upfront. A tub-to-shower conversion in El Monte runs $3,500-$10,000, while you can often refresh around an existing tub for well under that. Convert only when another tub on the property covers you for resale. Call (888) 271-7872 and we’ll price both so you can see the real gap.
It usually can. Most buyers for the city’s three-bedroom, one- and two-bath postwar homes expect at least one tub on the property, and taking the only one out can undercut your appraisal comps. If you have a second tub or an ADU with its own full bath, the concern largely disappears.
Walk-in shower installation in El Monte typically runs $4,500-$12,000, and a tub-to-shower conversion comes in around $3,500-$10,000. Bench, niche, and valve work push the number toward the top of the range. Estimates are free, so call (888) 271-7872 for an exact quote.
Yes, and it’s smart to plan both wet spaces at the same time. Once the ADU carries its own full bath, the main house is free to convert its tub alcove to a walk-in shower without leaving the property tub-less in the gap. We sequence the permits so the timing lines up. Call (888) 271-7872 to map it out.
If you’d rather have it looked at, Groundwork Construction Co. of El Monte offers a no-pressure assessment in El Monte. Call (888) 271-7872 for a free estimate and let’s settle the tub question with real numbers instead of guesswork.
Written by the team at Groundwork Construction Co. of El Monte, serving El Monte, CA.


